Employee Time Theft: Advice for Professionals

Employee time theft is a serious accusation with far-reaching implications for workers and employers. Recently, a court in British Columbia ordered a work-from-home employee to repay her employer $1,500 in overpaid wages after she failed to account for 50 hours of inactivity while she was supposed to be "on the clock." This ruling highlights uncertainty about what constitutes time theft in many workplaces and raises new employee concerns.

The concept of time theft is especially tricky to define and enforce when it comes to salaried positions. Typically, salaried employees do not envision themselves as “clock punchers” and believe they are entitled to some flexibility if they finish their work—traditionally, that has been one of the perks of salaried positions, right?

Broadly defined, time theft is when an employee claims to be working when they are not, and also encompasses actions such as asking a coworker to log in on their behalf or misrepresenting their location during working hours.

If you’ve been accused of time theft, consider seeking legal representation immediately.

Need more information on employee time theft? Share Lawyers can help secure what you’re entitled to.

Book a free consultation

Employee Time Theft Ruling: What to Know

Experts warn that companies could use electronic tracking and monitoring of remote employees as evidence of employee time theft.

This concern is particularly relevant as remote work continues to gain popularity, potentially leading to increased legal disputes.

Employee Time Theft: Key Points to Know

1. Remote Work Challenges

The rise in remote work heightens the likelihood of legal disputes using electronic monitoring to address time theft concerns.

2. Recent Case Precedent

The recent British Columbia case underscores the seriousness of time theft accusations, especially in remote work setups.

3. Impact of Electronic Monitoring

Ethical concerns arise as electronic monitoring may overly focus on measuring productivity solely based on hours worked.

4. Employee Rights & Transparency

Ontario legislation mandates that companies have clear policies on electronic monitoring and inform employees about monitoring methods.

5. Incentives for Employers

The "Working for Workers Act" mandates that companies create and update electronic monitoring policies, which introduces problematic incentives for employers to selectively enforce time theft accusations.

6. Privacy Concerns

While electronic monitoring can help uncover evidence of time theft, it is also invasive of employees' privacy, particularly professional remote employees who may find it difficult to account for every second where they are supposed to be working.

7. Legislation in Ontario & Other Provinces

While the act has been mandated in Ontario, it remains to be seen to what extent it will be applied to other provinces.

8. The Importance of Legal Advice

Accusations of time theft are serious and can lead to termination and liability for overpaid wages. Seeking legal advice is recommended for employees facing such accusations to understand their rights and options.

Concerns with the “Working for Workers Act”

Critics argue that the decision to make the employee repay her overpaid wages contradicts many employees' unspoken expectations.

Moreover, the ruling also creates problematic incentives for employers:

  • It financially rewards employers for the most invasive forms of digital monitoring.

  • It empowers employers to be selective in their enforcement of time theft policies against employees they consider undesirable.

Considerations for Employees

Employees should educate themselves about their employer's digital monitoring policy to protect themselves. In Ontario, most employers are required to have a digital monitoring policy. Employees should also ensure they can account for all the hours they are being paid, whether they are paid by the hour or their employer sets their working hours.

It remains to be seen whether and how this precedent will be applied in other provinces. For the most part, the issue of time theft in the age of digital monitoring remains a grey area.

If an employee is accused of time theft, it is a serious matter that can lead to termination without notice and liability for overpaid wages. Employees should seek legal advice to understand their rights and options in such cases.

Share is There to Represent You

If you worry about being held responsible for employee time theft accusations, having someone by your side who can offer accurate information and potential legal representation is crucial. Share Lawyers, a seasoned disability and employment law firm, advocates for employees' rights.

Navigating the complexities of employment law can be confusing and frustrating. We are committed to safeguarding employees' rights and offering a nuanced understanding of their situation to determine the optimal course of action. It all begins with a free consultation.

Need more information on employee time theft? We’ve got you covered.

Contact Share Lawyers today and put our experience to work for you. Our 35+ years of experience can help you win your case against Canada Life, Desjardins, Manulife, RBC Insurance, Sun Life, and other insurance companies. Our legal team offers a free consultation and works on a contingency basis - there are no fees unless you win your case.

We’re here to support you during this difficult time

How can we help?